Following months of public debate and community action, Amazon announced last week that it would continue to grow its workforce in New York, but would not follow through on plans to build a new campus in Queens. Through a deal negotiated by the governor and mayor behind closed doors and without legislative review, New York had offered Amazon nearly $3 billion in tax subsidies.
But the deal quickly became a flashpoint in public discussions around inequality, tax breaks for big business, and the power of monopolistic firms to bend the rules to their own advantage. The odds were long, but community organizing and public accountability ultimately prevailed.
While all eyes have been on New York, Amazon has begun to encounter similar opposition in northern Virginia and Nashville. And its ruthless HQ2 sweepstakes have inspired a new movement to limit corporate giveaways (follow Good Jobs First for latest on this).
ILSR’s Stacy Mitchell discussed the New York reversal on Chris Hayes on MSNBC, as well as Vice’s Motherboard, The Hill, and VentureBeat.
Our research and analysis of Amazon’s monopoly power was cited frequently in the HQ2 debate too, including our reports on Amazon’s ultimate ambitions and the company’s incursions into government procurement, and our commentary on its past history of public subsidies.
For other good commentary on the HQ2 saga, we recommend David Leonhardt’s column in the New York Times; this call-to-arms piece from last fall by Ron Kim and Zephyr Teachout, also in the Times; and this piece by Hamilton Nolan in Splinter.
If you liked this post, be sure to sign up for the monthly Hometown Advantage newsletter for our latest reporting and research.
Amazon maintains its monopoly power in part thanks to AI-driven pricing systems that monitor the cost of everything, often leading to higher prices for consumers.
ILSR's guide to hosting and supporting teacher wish lists without using Amazon.
ILSR's virtual event spotlights how pricing algorithms deployed by powerful corporations are inflating prices, undermining competition, and threatening independent businesses and communities.
ILSR outlines steps to prevent marketplace platforms like Amazon from listing your small business's products without permission.