While I generally have nothing but praise for the Environmental Protection Agency, their Green Power Partnership program falls short of the agency’s usual standard. In particular, the program – providing media recognition for participating companies who procure renewable energy – inflates the activities of large companies at the expense of businesses whose clean energy transformation is much more meaningful.
Take Wal-Mart, who appears at #3 in the EPA’s Green Power Partner rankings with an annual procurement of 872 million kilowatt-hours (enough to power approximately 87,000 homes per year). The EPA inaccurately credits the super-retailer with getting 28% of its electricity from green power, because the Partnership program allows Wal-Mart to cherry-pick its only two regional divisions that have made any strides on green energy (California and Texas).
But it’s not just that Wal-Mart can green its appearance by narrowing the focus to one or two company divisions. The truth is that many small businesses and towns (and even individuals) can lay claim to much more significant strides on renewable energy. For example, Oak Park, IL, recently signed a contract for 100% renewable electricity, nearly all of which comes from a wind power facility within the state. Bighorn Ace Hardware in Silverthorne, CO, gets 25% of its electricity from solar, built right on top of the building. Even this author can beat Wal-Mart, by using Xcel Energy’s Windsource to get 100% of his electricity from wind power.
In truth, Wal-Mart’s vast size means its green power steps have to be equally vast. To match the renewable energy commitment of Bighorn Hardware, for example, Wal-Mart would have to install over 5,500 megawatts of solar, three times more than was installed in the entire United States in 2011. And to be 100% renewable, it would have to install 20,000 megawatts, enough solar panels to make a bridge from New York to Los Angeles, 10 times over.
While Wal-Mart receives good press on its minor commitment to green power, neither Bighorn Ace Hardware nor Oak Park, IL, will make the EPA’s Top 50 list of Green Power Partners. That’s because EPA ranks businesses by the total size of their purchase, not their relative green-ness. The agency may as well list the Fortune 500 in order of electricity consumption.
It would be far more honest to rank companies by a meaningful metric of green power progress, like their green kilowatt-hours per dollar of sales.
The shame is not just that EPA employs the wrong measure of green, but that companies with big energy bills and small commitments to green power get great publicity at the expense of cities, colleges and businesses who have made real clean energy strides. EPA’s Green Power program could help highlight high-achievers in clean energy, but until its methodology changes, there will be a lot of entities on the list whose green thumbs are overshadowed by enormous energy footprints.